- Donna Forex Shoutbox

Welcome to the Donna Forex shoutbox! click "-" to hide it

Trade Advisor Pro

Started by Pipstar, Jul 13, 2012, 06:10 am

previous topic - next topic
Go Down

Total Badges: 0
Badges: (View All)

flatour


Look at the dates...I already told everyone about October. Ah, but you weren't with us in September so all you see if this tiny, narrow window at the beginning of October. So...see the attachments for September. This account is one of my copied accounts...directly from Mirror Trader Pro...any REAL member that was here in September can verify this. Look at the MT Rocket stats..it is exactly the same.

Josh




A good trader would never have 95% red trades. And a risk reward ratio like this... winnings 1-2 pips, losses 50-80 pips.

You are not a good trader.

And do you need help to setup myfxbook? Something to hide?

Did you offer free months to you october subscribers? You made them lost a lot and not the ability to recover.

    Looking For a Powerful Trade Copier?
    The Most Configurable MT4 Trade Copier In The Industry
    Local Trade Copier
    advertise here


    Total Badges: 0
    Badges: (View All)

    otoboke

    #25
    Oct 17, 2012, 01:49 pm Last Edit: Oct 17, 2012, 01:51 pm by otoboke
     ??? Come on, guys.

    Now I know my newbie status will probably discredit any opinion I have here, but looking at 1 or 2 weeks to judge a trader's ability is absolute BS. I'd like you to point out any "good trader" out there who hasn't had a string of losses inside of a week or two, even 95%. The fact is, even with those two weeks of drawdown, I myself am still in profit (13%) from where I was 6 weeks ago thanks to TAP. At the beginning of October I was up 24% from the end of August.

    If you took these trades and have found yourself in a position where you cannot recuperate, then that's all down to your risk management strategy and its obvious flaws. Unlike other providers, Josh preaches the importance of this aspect in trading.

    As for MTRocket, I personally take note of the trades listed on TAP's feed and compare them with my own, and guess what? They match. Surely if Josh was a "scammer", such losses would be stricken from the record, so to speak as is so often the case with actual fraudulent signal services. As a subscriber I can verify that losses are never overlooked, and Josh was big enough to admit to us all that what happened this month was unprecedented but also unacceptable due to the high exposure to falling markets.

    In summary, I think you guys need to take a step back and realise not everyone is out to steal your money and not everyone is perfect. In the meantime I'll be sticking around with TAP as I have actually profited first hand from this service many times and am not going to be knee-jerked into conspiracy theories and mob-mentality at the first sign of a drawdown.


      Total Badges: 0
      Badges: (View All)

      JoshTaylor



      Look at the dates...I already told everyone about October. Ah, but you weren't with us in September so all you see if this tiny, narrow window at the beginning of October. So...see the attachments for September. This account is one of my copied accounts...directly from Mirror Trader Pro...any REAL member that was here in September can verify this. Look at the MT Rocket stats..it is exactly the same.

      Josh




      A good trader would never have 95% red trades. And a risk reward ratio like this... winnings 1-2 pips, losses 50-80 pips.

      You are not a good trader.

      And do you need help to setup myfxbook? Something to hide?

      Did you offer free months to you october subscribers? You made them lost a lot and not the ability to recover.


      Are you blind? Look at the trade results for September. Where are you getting 95%? Also, look at the red. Just because a trade was stopped out does not mean it was stopped out at a loss. Download all 4 of the screenshots. Look at the Profit/Loss...Out of the 9 trades with "red"..meaning stopped out...5 of them were stopped at a loss. The other 4 were stopped in profit.

      We entered a trade. When price moves in our direction...85% of the time in September...we close out partial positions and move the stop up. We do this until we either decide to close the remaining lots OR we get stopped out in profit.

      You look like an idiot because the screenshots are right there. Show me how you got 95% losers? I'm done arguing with you.

      And folks, I am working right now on setting up with MyFXBook. And then we can all laugh because it is going to the SAME EXACT RESULTS...all data on MT Rocket, AGAIN...is automatically send to MT Rocket through the MT4 publish tab...the same way it works with MyFXBook...duh.

      So, unfortunately, MT4 only allows me to setup 1 publisher. So if any will respond to this post and let me know how to add MyFXBook, while still retaining MT Rocket...I will set it all up.

      By the way,

      Look at this:

      http://mirrortraderpro.mtrocket.com/

      Since we started third-party reporting on this VERIFIED account...We are down $3,937 on a $100,000 account. That is only a 3.9% drawdown. This is why you cannot judge a service in a week. Because you are not looking at the entire picture.

      Josh


        Total Badges: 0
        Badges: (View All)

        JoshTaylor


        ??? Come on, guys.

        Now I know my newbie status will probably discredit any opinion I have here, but looking at 1 or 2 weeks to judge a trader's ability is absolute BS. I'd like you to point out any "good trader" out there who hasn't had a string of losses inside of a week or two, even 95%. The fact is, even with those two weeks of drawdown, I myself am still in profit (13%) from where I was 6 weeks ago thanks to TAP. At the beginning of October I was up 24% from the end of August.

        If you took these trades and have found yourself in a position where you cannot recuperate, then that's all down to your risk management strategy and its obvious flaws. Unlike other providers, Josh preaches the importance of this aspect in trading.

        As for MTRocket, I personally take note of the trades listed on TAP's feed and compare them with my own, and guess what? They match. Surely if Josh was a "scammer", such losses would be stricken from the record, so to speak as is so often the case with actual fraudulent signal services. As a subscriber I can verify that losses are never overlooked, and Josh was big enough to admit to us all that what happened this month was unprecedented but also unacceptable due to the high exposure to falling markets.

        In summary, I think you guys need to take a step back and realise not everyone is out to steal your money and not everyone is perfect. In the meantime I'll be sticking around with TAP as I have actually profited first hand from this service many times and am not going to be knee-jerked into conspiracy theories and mob-mentality at the first sign of a drawdown.


        Thanks  :) I realize that this is how it works in FX. There are so many bad companies out there that everyone seems to be ready lynch a company if it has a bad day/week/month. Understandable. I built this business to help people and I will continue doing so.

        Thanks for the post. And glad you are enjoying the service!

        Josh Taylor


          Total Badges: 0
          Badges: (View All)

          JoshTaylor


          Anybody trading using Josh Taylor's Trade Advisor Pro signals(www.TradeAdvisorPro.com) , whether trading manually or automated?

          They have a special deal at the moment tradeadvisorpro.com/forex-signals-upgrade


          ...And Pipstar? If you go to our website and send an email to support, letting us know who you are? I will have my staff give you Pro Signals Direct, 1 month...for free so you can test it out. Then you can feel free to post your findings here.

          Thanks :-)

          Josh


            Total Badges: 0
            Badges: (View All)

            odysseus11

            Josh, its not a big complex thing to just add myfxbook, it has nothing to do with mt4 publisher, u can just add your mt4 account in myfxbook with the option "auto update" which can be selected when you add the account in myfxbook. If you just DO that, (and it is also helpful if you verify the account using their verification process) then we can see actual performance stats and this whole argument is moot. Everything you said makes sense but its all irrelevant without verified performance stats to back it up. Period. the rest is hot air and stuff we have all heard before.
              Odysseus


              Total Badges: 0
              Badges: (View All)

              JoshTaylor


              Josh, its not a big complex thing to just add myfxbook, it has nothing to do with mt4 publisher, u can just add your mt4 account in myfxbook with the option "auto update" which can be selected when you add the account in myfxbook. If you just DO that, (and it is also helpful if you verify the account using their verification process) then we can see actual performance stats and this whole argument is moot. Everything you said makes sense but its all irrelevant without verified performance stats to back it up. Period. the rest is hot air and stuff we have all heard before.


              Thanks...will start working on this. Hopefully the verification process is fast. Would like to have this up by the end of the week  :)

              Josh


                Total Badges: 0
                Badges: (View All)

                odysseus11

                it literally takes about 5 minutes
                  Odysseus

                  Go Up
                   


                  Views in last 7 daysLifeTime Views
                  post Wall Street Forex Robot
                  MetaTrader 4 Expert Advisors
                  11252 815913 kjen17
                  Mar 22, 2011, 07:39 pm
                  post PVSRA Trading Room
                  PVSRA with Traderathome
                  10002 26446 Traderathome
                  Jul 13, 2015, 02:14 am
                  post Easy Forex (ezefx.com)
                  MetaTrader 4 Expert Advisors
                  7152 322933 Mr Hector
                  Jul 16, 2010, 01:05 pm
                  post PVSRA Archive Thread
                  PVSRA with Traderathome
                  5469 56441 Traderathome
                  Jun 21, 2015, 10:38 pm
                  post FAPTurbo
                  Commercial (paid) Expert Advisors
                  5467 482757 admin
                  Apr 06, 2009, 02:57 pm
                  Likes in last 7 daysLifeTime Likes
                  post Re: PVSRA Trading Room
                  [ PVSRA with Traderathome ]
                  11 11 Pent56
                  Jul 27, 2015, 04:35 pm
                  post Re: PVSRA Trading Room
                  [ PVSRA with Traderathome ]
                  9 9 Traderathome
                  Jul 31, 2015, 04:08 pm
                  post Re: PVSRA Trading Room
                  [ PVSRA with Traderathome ]
                  6 6 Traderathome
                  Jul 31, 2015, 02:22 pm
                  post Re: PVSRA Trading Room
                  [ PVSRA with Traderathome ]
                  5 5 leentjai
                  Jul 26, 2015, 11:59 am
                  post Re: PVSRA Trading Room
                  [ PVSRA with Traderathome ]
                  5 5 Traderathome
                  Jul 28, 2015, 09:54 am