FOREXTHOR

[Josef]

I got price reduction coupon to Thor. Would you suggest to buy this EA? Making consistent profit? What is average monthly ROI for you who have been using this more than one month?

All the best,

V

If you care about broker/VPS combination, the chance is high that Thor will make money for you.


Ok, here the updated performance from my Thor accounts:

First account (C1 Aggressive=true, C2, C3)
This week: -4.42%
Month to date: +23.27%
Last trades: -3.4, +0.6, +0.2 Pips

Second account (C1 Aggressive=false, C2, C3)
This week: +2.03%
Month to date: +28.19%
Last trades: +3.0, +0.5, +0.1 Pips

Have a good weekend!
Josef

[crashev]

My results from 24:

broker1: -5,9 pips
broker2: -1 pips

[lxboston]

Results from 24th,

+0.8  and -0.3

[Manohar]

Advertisement

Josef,
can u tell me, how does thor works on synergyfx-ECN Account

[elmer]

Anyone know where I can get a price reduction coupon for Thor. I would like to purchase it. Thanks

[Young]

Anyone know where I can get a price reduction coupon for Thor. I would like to purchase it. Thanks

I kindly asked their support support@forexthor.com for mine, and they gave me one. I guess, if you act politely and kindly, you can get all you want

[Josef]

Josef,
can u tell me, how does thor works on synergyfx-ECN Account.

I remember that MDP was running well on Synergy accounts. Probably it's a good broker for scalping.

[Byte]

Hi Josef,
I did run Forex Thor on a Synergy FX-ECN account out of a beeks VPS and results were not as good as those I had with Pepperstone and those are still worse than those you report. I ran it from middle of April to end of May and lost about 58 pips

   Open Date   Close date   Symbol   Action    Lots   SL   TP   Open Price   Close Price   Pips   Net Profit   Duration   Gain   

05.30.2012 11:00    05.30.2012 11:01   EURUSD    Sell   0.72    1.24629    1.24479    1.24568    1.24633   -6.5   -41.58    10s    -1.91%      

05.30.2012 11:00    05.30.2012 11:01   EURUSD    Sell   0.72    1.24629    1.24479    1.24563    1.24633   -7.0   -44.47    10s    -2.08%      

05.24.2012 13:00    05.24.2012 13:01   EURUSD    Sell   0.59    1.26093    1.25923    1.26059    1.26094   -3.5   -19.64    47s    -0.83%      

05.24.2012 08:00    05.24.2012 08:01   EURUSD    Buy   0.56    1.25237    1.25407    1.25221    1.25230   0.9   0.88    47s    0.04%      

05.24.2012 08:00    05.24.2012 08:00   EURUSD    Buy   0.57    1.25208    1.25378    1.25251    1.25188   -6.3   -31.87    12s    -1.36%      

05.23.2012 14:18    05.23.2012 14:18   EURUSD    Buy   0.45    1.26011    1.26181    1.26008    1.26010   0.2   -1.78    39s    -0.08%      

05.23.2012 14:17    05.23.2012 14:18   EURUSD    Buy   0.56    1.26005    1.26175    1.26004    1.25995   -0.9   -7.10    17s    -0.31%      

05.23.2012 14:17    05.23.2012 14:17   EURUSD    Buy   0.56    1.26011    1.26181    1.26017    1.26011   -0.6   -5.77    10s    -0.25%      

05.18.2012 19:06    05.18.2012 19:07   EURUSD    Buy   0.57    1.27594    1.27764    1.27653    1.27594   -5.9   -29.47    12s    -1.29%      

05.18.2012 19:05    05.18.2012 19:06   EURUSD    Sell   0.57    1.27796    1.27626    1.27826    1.27814   1.2   2.24    13s    0.10%      

05.18.2012 19:05    05.18.2012 19:05   EURUSD    Sell   0.57    1.27760    1.27590    1.27820    1.27809   1.1   1.80    6s    0.08%      

05.18.2012 19:04    05.18.2012 19:05   EURUSD    Sell   0.55    1.27726    1.27556    1.27792    1.27731   6.1   23.27    33s    1.03%      

05.18.2012 19:04    05.18.2012 19:05   EURUSD    Sell   0.55    1.27728    1.27558    1.27777    1.27728   4.9   18.10    29s    0.81%      

05.18.2012 19:04    05.18.2012 19:05   EURUSD    Sell   0.55    1.27726    1.27556    1.27777    1.27731   4.6   16.81    29s    0.75%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:50   EURUSD    Buy   0.56    1.26843    1.27013    1.26894    1.26827   -6.7   -32.68    54s    -1.45%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:50   EURUSD    Buy   0.56    1.26841    1.27011    1.26872    1.26828   -4.4   -22.53    1m    -1.01%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:49   EURUSD    Buy   0.57    1.26840    1.27010    1.26867    1.26839   -2.8   -15.73    9s    -0.68%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:49   EURUSD    Buy   0.57    1.26840    1.27010    1.26896    1.26839   -5.7   -28.77    4s    -1.26%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:49   EURUSD    Buy   0.59    1.26793    1.26963    1.26872    1.26793   -7.9   -40.02    2s    -1.67%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:49   EURUSD    Buy   0.59    1.26792    1.26962    1.26879    1.26782   -9.7   -48.40    2s    -2.06%   
   Open Date   Close date   Symbol   Action    Lots   SL   TP   Open Price   Close Price   Pips   Net Profit   Duration   Gain   

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:49   EURUSD    Buy   0.61    1.26622    1.26792    1.26841    1.26803   -3.8   -21.65    0s    -0.89%      

05.17.2012 21:49    05.17.2012 21:49   EURUSD    Buy   0.61    1.26618    1.26788    1.26841    1.26788   -5.3   -28.87    0s    -1.19%      

04.19.2012 08:40    04.19.2012 08:41   EURUSD    Sell   0.55    1.31596    1.31426    1.31604    1.31605   -0.1   -3.35    21s    -0.15%      

04.19.2012 08:40    04.19.2012 08:40   EURUSD    Sell   0.56    1.31593    1.31423    1.31562    1.31598   -3.6   -18.30    11s    -0.81%      

04.19.2012 08:40    04.19.2012 08:40   EURUSD    Sell   0.56    1.31592    1.31422    1.31606    1.31595   1.1   1.70    13s    0.08%      

04.17.2012 09:00    04.17.2012 09:02   EURUSD    Sell   0.56    1.31670    1.31500    1.31700    1.31676   2.4   7.23    1m    0.32%   

[Josef]

Hi Josef,
I did run Forex Thor on a Synergy FX-ECN account out of a beeks VPS and results were not as good as those I had with Pepperstone and those are still worse than those you report. I ran it from middle of April to end of May and lost about 58 pips

Hi Byte,
I just checked my results (04.17.2012 - 05.30.2012) and saw that Thor placed 43 trades during this period while you had only 26 or 27 trades. Probably, we were using different settings?

Best Regards,
Josef

[Forex2k11]

I got price reduction coupon to Thor. Would you suggest to buy this EA? Making consistent profit? What is average monthly ROI for you who have been using this more than one month?

All the best,

V

If you care about broker/VPS combination, the chance is high that Thor will make money for you.


Ok, here the updated performance from my Thor accounts:

First account (C1 Aggressive=true, C2, C3)
This week: -4.42%
Month to date: +23.27%
Last trades: -3.4, +0.6, +0.2 Pips

Second account (C1 Aggressive=false, C2, C3)
This week: +2.03%
Month to date: +28.19%
Last trades: +3.0, +0.5, +0.1 Pips

Have a good weekend!
Josef

May I ask what your brokers are for those two accounts?

[Byte]

Fair point. I run it with aggressive off ....  If I remember correctly you use aggressive. But also Synergy for me had less trades than Pepperstone.

Hi Josef,
I did run Forex Thor on a Synergy FX-ECN account out of a beeks VPS and results were not as good as those I had with Pepperstone and those are still worse than those you report. I ran it from middle of April to end of May and lost about 58 pips

Hi Byte,
I just checked my results (04.17.2012 - 05.30.2012) and saw that Thor placed 43 trades during this period while you had only 26 or 27 trades. Probably, we were using different settings?

Best Regards,
Josef

[Josef]

But also Synergy for me had less trades than Pepperstone.

There can be several reasons for...

..Different price aggregation
..Different liquidity venues (Synergy uses UK venues while Pepper uses US venues (NY4))
..Different spread
..Different execution technology

Josef

[Josef]

I was sure the US Unemployment Claims will bring us some new trades. 

[crashev]

Today's results:

broker1: +0.8 pips
broker2: -4.5 pips - and I will be droping this one

Very disturbing thing in Vendor's myfxbook account at http://www.myfxbook.com/members/thorforex/thor-ii-live-account/288808

It looks like there was some kind of manual intervention there.

[supern0va3000]

I attach this picture which includes August Thor2 Trades in my Thinkforex Pro/Beeks fx VPS.

I started running Core1 non aggressive starting second week of August , and added Core2,Core3 in the last week of August.
I changed the settings to fixed lot size after the first losing trade.

When I compare my results to Josef and to Forexpeacearmy test Live test , it shows a great difference. I got 3 trades this month , all on Core1 , All losing.
I think this month is enough for me to know that Thor2 is BROKER-DEPENDENT !
For September I will continue running Thor2 on Core2,3 only , with also small fixed lot size and see how it goes.

I will NOT ask for a refund , as I beleive this EA can be amazing on certain brokers. Josef's account and Forexpeacearmy proves that clearly. I think I will open an account in ILQ.

Regards all/